Cryptology Sheffield: The Mysterious Case of Hugh Dunnitt

By | March 19, 2021

by Cryptology Sheffield (website)

141 West Street

​0114 483 0052

Up to 6 players

£15.00

Languages: EN

🖥digital
not on sale

You and your team must investigate the murder of Hugh Dunnitt and find out why he was killed and who killed him.

Unlock all of the clues, but be careful. There is something else afoot.

Investigate what’s happening on West Street, and you may become embroiled in a struggle for more than just the truth!

show full description
Thank you for helping keep Escape the Review up to date!
Let us know what needs changing:




If you own or manage this company, you can also claim the listing and update it yourself

Overall rating

Rated between 3.5 and 4 out of 5

based on ratings from 27 users
combined with 2 pro reviews

Your review

Player reviews

Anonymous rated this:Rated between 40 and 40 out of 5

Very entertaining and unique!  Light-hearted and refreshing game, really good implementation into digital format.

Anonymous rated this:Rated between 40 and 40 out of 5

Played solo, good fun.

Angie rated this:Rated between 50 and 50 out of 5

Brilliantly constructed game with great humour, highly recommend it.

Anonymous rated this:Rated between 50 and 50 out of 5
Anonymous rated this:Rated between 50 and 50 out of 5

I played this with my after school STEM students and they loved it!! It was just hard enough for us. They are middle schoolers. Thank you!! 

hasteve rated this:Rated between 50 and 50 out of 5
value for moneyfunnystory-driven
Had an amazing time in the Hugh Dunnit room. Great puzzles and atmosphere.
Our game master Johnathan was good fun and got things off to a perfect start.
Can't wait to try the other rooms!
Anne expert rated this:Rated between 35 and 35 out of 5
story-drivenvery easy
We just flew through this one. Wish we had played it in real life as we would have liked to watch some specific game mechanic IRL. 

We love detective type stories and this one delivered. It is quite easy and is probably best for beginners, but we also had fun.

Part one was really what we came for - the plot twist in part two was not really our cup of tea storywise, but the puzzles were fine and not hard. You could probably say that this escape game is more focused on the story than the puzzles and that makes it very inclusive also for a younger demographic. 

Tech wise this is based on the telescape platform and it worked well all the way except for sounds, where some was very low in volume and some was very high in volume. Lots of videos used to create the story. 
🎲A Jones experienced rated this:Rated between 35 and 35 out of 5
Played: 11 Feb 2024 Team size: 2 Time taken: 44:12 Outcome: Successful escape!
originalstory-driven
Good fun room. It starts off slow and seems a bit like an old fashioned style escape room but then as you get further into it, it gets better and better and the pace feels like it picks up.
SiSitAndWait rated this:Rated between 45 and 45 out of 5
Played: 22 Jan 2022 Team size: 4 Time taken: 47:55 Outcome: Successful escape!
immersivestory-drivengreat hostingquite easy

A murder mystery done very different kept us on our toes! It had some puzzles we had not seen before and whilst it was on the easier side it was very enjoyable.

The interactive system used in the game is like nothing I had seen!

Anonymous rated this:Rated between 15 and 15 out of 5
Anne expert rated this:Rated between 35 and 35 out of 5
Played: 31 Jul 2021 Team size: 2
story-drivenvery easy

We just flew through this one. Wish we had played it in real life as we would have liked to watch some specific game mechanic IRL. 

We love detective type stories and this one delivered. It is quite easy and is probably best for beginners, but we also had fun.

Part one was really what we came for - the plot twist in part two was not really our cup of tea storywise, but the puzzles were fine and not hard. You could probably say that this escape game is more focused on the story than the puzzles and that makes it very inclusive also for a younger demographic. 

Tech wise this is based on the telescape platform and it worked well all the way except for sounds, where some was very low in volume and some was very high in volume. Lots of videos used to create the story. 




Amy Lowson rated this:Rated between 35 and 35 out of 5
Played: 11 Sep 2021 Team size: 5 Outcome: Successful escape!
abooth expert rated this:Rated between 40 and 40 out of 5
Played: 22 Jan 2022 Team size: 2 Time taken: 52 Outcome: Successful escape!
value for moneyoriginal

Enjoyed this a lot - some original puzzles, lovely flow to it.

The Monkey expert rated this:Rated between 30 and 30 out of 5

Enjoyed the room, interesting with the way they've decided to create this room in terms of story line. Not the usual ending. 

Anonymous rated this:Rated between 25 and 25 out of 5
Played: 16 Jul 2022 Team size: 2 Time taken: 52 Outcome: Successful escape!
story-drivenbroken tech
samcrashb4 rated this:Rated between 35 and 35 out of 5
Played: 16 Dec 2023 Team size: 2 Time taken: 49:11 Outcome: Successful escape!
story-drivenbroken tech
Overall a fun game, most puzzles were fairly logical and we enjoyed them! One or two more challenging puzzles also helped make this room very fun! 
The clue system is very creative, however we did find the clue system in the second half to be a bit confusing at times, hard to pick apart actual clues from story/theming... But it did work well for this story driven room.
The room is advertised as a murder mystery, however the story takes a bit of a turn toward the magical around the halfway point and we thought the themes clashed a bit, especially from what the room is advertised as.
There were a couple of points where we had some broken tech, one of the automatically opening parts needed an extra whack from us and we had a tough time getting something laser related to activate. But I wouldn't say this was overly detrimental to our experience!
Overall it is definitely worth a playthrough at very least and we will be back to try their other rooms at some point in the future!
Jordan Brown experienced rated this:Rated between 35 and 35 out of 5
Played: 14 Feb 2022 Team size: 2 Time taken: 46:55 Outcome: Successful escape!
originalfamily friendly

A fairly common theme but the story takes an interesting turn. Clue system is very inventive and the theming, whilst initially sparse and uninspiring, is done well overall. Some good puzzles (if not a tad frustrating) and great logic/flow.

SpookyEm rated this:Rated between 40 and 40 out of 5
Played: 10 Sep 2022 Team size: 2 Time taken: 37 Outcome: Successful escape!
clevergreat hostingdifferentquite easy

Really enjoyed this escape room. Very different to standard “get out the door” ones. Found the storyline a little odd, but was good fun nonetheless. I liked the use of tech and and the different setting were so different, it was cool. 

HauntedCryme rated this:Rated between 25 and 25 out of 5
Played: 16/02/2020 Team size: 2 Outcome: Successful escape!
story-drivenbroken techquite easy
🤘The Pick of Destiny expert rated this:Rated between 30 and 30 out of 5
TeamDenton experienced rated this:Rated between 40 and 40 out of 5
Team size: 2 Time taken: 50 ish mins Outcome: Successful escape!
great hosting

The hosts at cryptology are great and they always make time to discuss the room with us afterwards. We enjoyed this room a lot, but I would say slightly less than their other two rooms (Afterlife and First Contact). The set dressing felt a little less immersive and there was a bit that had a lot of recorded noise which got a little overwhelming (but maybe we were just taking too long 😅). Overall good fun with plenty to do.

Lorraine Downing experienced rated this:Rated between 40 and 40 out of 5
Team size: 2 Outcome: Successful escape!
value for moneystory-driven
Jen Wells (Get Wells Soon) expert rated this:Rated between 30 and 30 out of 5
Played: 25 Nov 2023 Team size: 2 Time taken: 22 mins Outcome: Successful escape!
story-drivengreat hosting

A solid offering with some nice quirks and straightforward puzzles. It is definitely one that's on the easy side, as we flew through it, but that's not to say it wasn't enjoyable and we appreciated the different kind of take on a common theme.

The hosting here is incredibly friendly and welcoming.

Mark Crossley experienced rated this:Rated between 30 and 30 out of 5
Played: 09/09/2022 Team size: 2 Time taken: 31:59 Outcome: Successful escape!
great hostingplainquite easy
🔐SpontaneousIllusion expert rated this:Rated between 35 and 35 out of 5
flyingoctopus expert rated this:Rated between 35 and 35 out of 5
Outcome: Successful escape!
🔐James Bloodworth expert rated this:Rated between 40 and 40 out of 5
Played: 14/03/2020 Team size: 4 Time taken: 38:20 Outcome: Successful escape!
Clever puzzles with an interesting back story combine to make this worth going out of your way for.  We played as a group of 4 but enthusiasts could probably do this as a 2, theres a lot do but it is well structured and is played in two halves with both taking on a non-linear path to victory.

Reviews by escape room review sites

This is a really fun room with the ‘things to do’ element of the room meaning everyone can get really stuck in and feel properly involved. The clue system, as with Cryptology’s other rooms, is interactive and funny, and perfectly designed to fit in with the room’s story and theme, making it a thoroughly immersive experience. Additionally, as you progress through the room the pressure ramps up to encourage you to get everything solved in time. This is cleverly done and Hugh Dunnitt is a really enjoyable and commendable room!

See also

Other versions of this game:(Different copies of the same game sometimes have significant differences.)