Escape From The Room: Return of Old Maid Milly

By | July 21, 2020

by Escape From The Room (website)

Depot Rd, Epsom KT17 4RJ

Sutton

2-8 players

60 minutes

Years have past since Dr Alan Harris and his team of Paranormal Investigators discovered the truth behind the the infamously named Curse of Old Maid Milly. The eponymous spirit had seemed to have found peace, but now suddenly, years on, the bedroom where Old Maid Milly had previously lived with her many cats has become a hive of supernatural activity again. When an inquisitive group of ghost hunters disappeared after making their way into the once haunted bedroom it was a clear signal of the Return of Old Maid Milly.
show full description
Thank you for helping keep Escape the Review up to date!
Let us know what needs changing:




If you own or manage this company, you can also claim the listing and update it yourself

Overall rating

Rated between 2 and 4 out of 5

based on ratings from 5 users
combined with 3 pro reviews

Your review

Player reviews

benny1664 experienced rated this:Rated between 2 and 2 out of 5
Played: 22 Aug 2025 Team size: 3 Time taken: 45 Outcome: Successful escape!
broken techpoor hostingplain

Sadly this room was a real let down.  We have done 7 or 8 of these guys rooms at Epsom, Wallington, Horton Park and Sevenoaks and this was the worst by far.  Some of the others are great games (Crabheel, Aviary of Spies, Hex) and I just don't see how this game fitted with everything else they have produced.  I did the Maid Milly game at Horton Park and that was great, I liked the theme and set a lot, it was just too easy.  But this game was very cheaply built and lacked any character, it was very very home built DIY/bodged. 

Did'nt think the GM was very good either.  We got sooooo many clues and prompts which as an experienced team of 100 games each was'nt really needed and the clues also interupt the flow as you have to go back onto room one and read off a mirror.  Also, we spent ages opening a lock when we clearly had the correct code and in the end we had to pass it through a hatch to be opened as it had a tough padlock on it.  Sorry but we had the correct code and it should have been spotted there was an issue sooner.  

Do the other games at their venues but avoid this one as it seems sub standard!

🦡cipherdelic virtuoso rated this:Rated between 2.5 and 2.5 out of 5
Played: August 2023
dangerous

Showing its age now, took a chunk out of my finger on an exposed screw on a botched repair.

🔐James Bloodworth expert rated this:Rated between 3 and 3 out of 5
Played: 28 Aug 2023 Team size: 2 Outcome: Successful escape!
😨creepy

A relatively creepy room using all of the tropes you might expect of a haunting of this nature.  We had a couple of reset/prop fails in this room but it didn't impede our process too much.  Clue system was in keeping with the room and we only needed them for out search fails.  As someone else has noted, this is more of a scooby doo room than outright scares.

jakea256 expert rated this:Rated between 4 and 4 out of 5
😨creepy

Scooby doo horror rather than out and out horror. A few jump scares but nothing too extreme. The second half puzzles were a bit more invovled than the first and had some clever uses of the space (no spoilers). Traditional room done very well!

Ronnie Meade experienced rated this:Rated between 3.5 and 3.5 out of 5
Played: 30 Jan 2022 Team size: 2 Outcome: Successful escape!
immersive😨creepy

A good game with little scares throughout to keep you on your toes. A good range of puzzles from logic, practical, teamwork and communication. There is a fair amount of back and forth so don't be scared to go back into the first room. A good venue with an array of games to play. 

Reviews by escape room review sites

Old Maid Milly was the ghost in Escape From The Room’s very first game, originally built in the upstairs bedroom of a suburban house. That game resolved the ghost’s tragic past and laid her spirit to rest, but here she’s back and has you trapped again.

The setting did feel less authentic than that of the original Old Maid Milly game - because it is less authentic, being a commercial space decorated to look like a bedroom rather than an actual bedroom. In other respects it’s a lot like it...

This was our first post-lockdown physical escape room, and it was a good one. Escape from the Room have upped their game and we would have no problems recommending this room
A fun game that really demonstrates the step up that Escape from the Room has made over the last few years. With a thirty minute extension option, this is a particularly fun game for enthusiasts who want to take their time and savour the game.

Lists

This game is part of the following user-created game lists:
Escape Roomers DE - Ranked Playlist United Kingdom by Escape Roomers De expert

[Last Update: January 2026] I’ve visited the United Kingdom several times and played a total of 173 escape games from 61 different providers. As always, I’ve asked also other enthusiasts and bloggers for their opinions. The final table combines the individual rankings of 63 enthusiasts...

See also